Keep the Card or Cancel It? How Your Credit Limit Shapes Your Score
Picture two credit cards, each with a $5,000 limit, and $2,000 owing between them. You're using 20% of the credit available to you. Cancel the card you never touch and that same $2,000 now sits against a single $5,000 limit, so you're at 40%. You haven't spent a dollar more, and your score can still slide.
That small piece of math sits under every keep-or-cancel decision: your unused limit does quiet work for your score every month. Maybe it's a materials card you only lean on in busy season, or a starter card from years ago, and you're saving for a first home. Either way, the choice deserves the same side-by-side look you'd give any money decision, because a few points matter when a lender pulls your file.
Your score watches the ratio
Credit utilization, the share of your available credit you're using, makes up roughly 30% of your score with Equifax and TransUnion. Only payment history, at about 35%, carries more weight. Most credit guidance suggests keeping total utilization under 30%.
Timing matters too. Card companies report your statement balance, so if you pay in full after the statement date, the bureaus may still see the higher number. Paying a few days before the statement closes keeps the reported figure low.
Keeping it costs little and is easy to manage
A no-fee card sitting in a drawer costs you nothing and keeps its limit on your file. If it's one of your oldest accounts, it also props up the length of your credit history. Accounts older than about seven to ten years are treated as mature and help the most.
The effort is minor. Some issuers close accounts that go unused, so put one small recurring bill on it, like a streaming subscription, and set up automatic full payment from your chequing account. The card stays active and never carries a balance. That autopay is your safeguard: at 20.99%, the typical purchase rate BMO lists as of October 2026, a forgotten balance would cost you far more than the card is worth.
Cancelling can make sense for the right reasons
Cancelling wins in a couple of real situations. If the card carries an annual fee, say an illustrative $150, and gives you nothing back, you're paying cash every year for score protection. Ask about downgrading to a no-fee card with the same issuer, which usually keeps the account and its age intact.
The other reason is behaviour. If an open card keeps pulling you into spending you regret, closing it can be the healthier call, even with a dip. Scores generally recover within three to six months when the rest of your habits stay steady. Just avoid closing one card only to open another, since a new application adds a hard inquiry, typically a 5 to 10 point dip.
If you simply dislike a card, there's a middle path: ask for a limit increase on the card you do use before closing anything. Your total credit, and your ratio, stay roughly where they were.
The condition that decides it
The deciding question is whether you'll apply for a mortgage or other major credit in the next six months or so.
In BC, lenders typically look for a score around 680 or higher for their best "A" lender rates, and CMHC's insured program for self-employed borrowers sets a minimum score of 600. A 20-point slide at the wrong moment can move you from one tier to another, and that shows up in your monthly payment. If your tax returns show modest net income after business write-offs, a strong score is one of the things that helps your file stand up.
So if a purchase, refinance or renewal is on the horizon, keep the card open until your mortgage funds and the keys are in your hand. If nothing big is coming for a year or more, close it on your own terms, ideally after paying your balances down first.
Not sure how your limits are reading right now? A quick file review with a broker before you make the call takes the guesswork out, and it's an easy conversation to start.
Picture two credit cards, each with a $5,000 limit, and $2,000 owing between them. You're using 20% of the credit available to you. Cancel the card you never touch and that same $2,000 now sits against a single $5,000 limit, so you're at 40%. You haven't spent a dollar more, and your score can still slide.
That small piece of math sits under every keep-or-cancel decision: your unused limit does quiet work for your score every month. Maybe it's a materials card you only lean on in busy season, or a starter card from years ago, and you're saving for a first home. Either way, the choice deserves the same side-by-side look you'd give any money decision, because a few points matter when a lender pulls your file.
Your score watches the ratio
Credit utilization, the share of your available credit you're using, makes up roughly 30% of your score with Equifax and TransUnion. Only payment history, at about 35%, carries more weight. Most credit guidance suggests keeping total utilization under 30%.
Timing matters too. Card companies report your statement balance, so if you pay in full after the statement date, the bureaus may still see the higher number. Paying a few days before the statement closes keeps the reported figure low.
Keeping it costs little and is easy to manage
A no-fee card sitting in a drawer costs you nothing and keeps its limit on your file. If it's one of your oldest accounts, it also props up the length of your credit history. Accounts older than about seven to ten years are treated as mature and help the most.
The effort is minor. Some issuers close accounts that go unused, so put one small recurring bill on it, like a streaming subscription, and set up automatic full payment from your chequing account. The card stays active and never carries a balance. That autopay is your safeguard: at 20.99%, the typical purchase rate BMO lists as of October 2026, a forgotten balance would cost you far more than the card is worth.
Cancelling can make sense for the right reasons
Cancelling wins in a couple of real situations. If the card carries an annual fee, say an illustrative $150, and gives you nothing back, you're paying cash every year for score protection. Ask about downgrading to a no-fee card with the same issuer, which usually keeps the account and its age intact.
The other reason is behaviour. If an open card keeps pulling you into spending you regret, closing it can be the healthier call, even with a dip. Scores generally recover within three to six months when the rest of your habits stay steady. Just avoid closing one card only to open another, since a new application adds a hard inquiry, typically a 5 to 10 point dip.
If you simply dislike a card, there's a middle path: ask for a limit increase on the card you do use before closing anything. Your total credit, and your ratio, stay roughly where they were.
The condition that decides it
The deciding question is whether you'll apply for a mortgage or other major credit in the next six months or so.
In BC, lenders typically look for a score around 680 or higher for their best "A" lender rates, and CMHC's insured program for self-employed borrowers sets a minimum score of 600. A 20-point slide at the wrong moment can move you from one tier to another, and that shows up in your monthly payment. If your tax returns show modest net income after business write-offs, a strong score is one of the things that helps your file stand up.
So if a purchase, refinance or renewal is on the horizon, keep the card open until your mortgage funds and the keys are in your hand. If nothing big is coming for a year or more, close it on your own terms, ideally after paying your balances down first.
Not sure how your limits are reading right now? A quick file review with a broker before you make the call takes the guesswork out, and it's an easy conversation to start.
Sources
Read Next
Standard Charge or Collateral Charge at Renewal? Here is Who Each One Is For
Why Your Pre-Approval Number Is the Wrong Place to Start
Pay Down Total Debt or Lower Your Monthly Payments? Here is Who Each One Is For
Before You Sign an Auto-Renewal: How to Check if Breaking Your Term Pays Off