Clear the Line of Credit or Book More Work? Mortgage Math Favours One
Your calendar is booked into spring, invoices are going out on time and your credit report is spotless. Then a pre-approval comes back lower than you expected, and the natural reaction is to take on more jobs, because more work has always solved money questions before. Before you give up your Saturdays, it helps to know what the lender is actually measuring. Sometimes the quickest route to more mortgage room is a statement you already pay every month.
Maybe you've looked at a full schedule and a clean credit file and wondered why your budget still feels tight. Often the gap comes from the personal payments you carry: the line of credit that covered a slow winter, the truck payment, the card you use for supplies. Each one claims part of the same monthly room your mortgage needs.
When those payments are what's holding you back, paying one off can create more room than earning the same amount of extra income. Knowing which situation you're in tells you where your cash and your evenings should go.
Which creates more mortgage room: less debt or more income?
Lenders run two checks.
Gross debt service (GDS) compares your housing costs (mortgage payment, property tax and heat) to your gross income.
Total debt service (TDS) adds every other personal payment you make.
CMHC sets the maximums at 39% for GDS and 44% for TDS on insured mortgages. Many lenders work with similar limits, though every file is assessed on its own.
Here's an illustrative example. Say you carry $20,000 on an unsecured personal line of credit. Many lenders assess revolving balances at 3% of the balance per month, whatever minimum your statement shows. That's a $600 monthly obligation.
To absorb $600 inside a 44% TDS limit, you'd need about $1,364 more qualifying income every month ($600 ÷ 0.44), or roughly $16,364 a year. If you pay the line off and the lender sees it documented, the $600 drops out of the calculation entirely.
What is that $600 worth? At a hypothetical 6% qualifying rate over 25 years, $600 a month supports roughly $94,000 of mortgage principal. That holds only when TDS is the limit that binds, and only if GDS, the property and your down payment allow it.
Keep in mind that you qualify at a stress-test rate, which is the higher of your contract rate plus 2% or 5.25%. The rate you'd actually pay is usually lower.
Why paying off debt is not always the better move
Timing usually favours repayment. New work rarely changes your qualifying income quickly. Lenders typically look at about two years of documented earnings from your tax returns, after expenses. Your business revenue and the income a lender will accept are different numbers. A paid-off balance, once it appears on your credit report and statements, can change the math within weeks.
Cash favours caution. The money that clears a line of credit may be the same money set aside for your down payment, closing costs or your tax bill. A better ratio does you no good if you get the keys and then can't cover what you owe CRA or carry the business through a quiet month. And if GDS or the property's costs are the real limit, repaying debt won't move your number at all.
Before you decide:
Ask what payment the lender assigns to each debt. A revolving balance may be assessed well above your minimum.
Compare debt reduction with extra qualifying income, not extra sales. A $20,000 job might add far less after expenses, and it may not count until it shows up in your tax returns.
Request two scenarios on the same property: one with the debt kept and one with it repaid. The difference shows whether debt payments, housing costs or something else is the real constraint.
Protect your down payment, closing costs, tax money and operating reserve first. Pay debt only from what's left over.
What to do before you apply
That busy owner with the full calendar and the disappointing pre-approval isn't being judged on effort. A lender sees three things: documented income, assessed payments and the cash you have available. Once you know which of those is pinching, you can work on the right one.
Your first move is simple. Pick one existing balance, usually the line of credit or card with the highest assessed payment. Ask your broker to run the numbers with it kept and with it repaid, before you spend savings or take on extra work just to qualify.
I'm happy to run both scenarios with you, so the decision rests on your real numbers rather than a guess.
Your calendar is booked into spring, invoices are going out on time and your credit report is spotless. Then a pre-approval comes back lower than you expected, and the natural reaction is to take on more jobs, because more work has always solved money questions before. Before you give up your Saturdays, it helps to know what the lender is actually measuring. Sometimes the quickest route to more mortgage room is a statement you already pay every month.
Maybe you've looked at a full schedule and a clean credit file and wondered why your budget still feels tight. Often the gap comes from the personal payments you carry: the line of credit that covered a slow winter, the truck payment, the card you use for supplies. Each one claims part of the same monthly room your mortgage needs.
When those payments are what's holding you back, paying one off can create more room than earning the same amount of extra income. Knowing which situation you're in tells you where your cash and your evenings should go.
Which creates more mortgage room: less debt or more income?
Lenders run two checks.
CMHC sets the maximums at 39% for GDS and 44% for TDS on insured mortgages. Many lenders work with similar limits, though every file is assessed on its own.
Here's an illustrative example. Say you carry $20,000 on an unsecured personal line of credit. Many lenders assess revolving balances at 3% of the balance per month, whatever minimum your statement shows. That's a $600 monthly obligation.
To absorb $600 inside a 44% TDS limit, you'd need about $1,364 more qualifying income every month ($600 ÷ 0.44), or roughly $16,364 a year. If you pay the line off and the lender sees it documented, the $600 drops out of the calculation entirely.
What is that $600 worth? At a hypothetical 6% qualifying rate over 25 years, $600 a month supports roughly $94,000 of mortgage principal. That holds only when TDS is the limit that binds, and only if GDS, the property and your down payment allow it.
Keep in mind that you qualify at a stress-test rate, which is the higher of your contract rate plus 2% or 5.25%. The rate you'd actually pay is usually lower.
Why paying off debt is not always the better move
Timing usually favours repayment. New work rarely changes your qualifying income quickly. Lenders typically look at about two years of documented earnings from your tax returns, after expenses. Your business revenue and the income a lender will accept are different numbers. A paid-off balance, once it appears on your credit report and statements, can change the math within weeks.
Cash favours caution. The money that clears a line of credit may be the same money set aside for your down payment, closing costs or your tax bill. A better ratio does you no good if you get the keys and then can't cover what you owe CRA or carry the business through a quiet month. And if GDS or the property's costs are the real limit, repaying debt won't move your number at all.
Before you decide:
What to do before you apply
That busy owner with the full calendar and the disappointing pre-approval isn't being judged on effort. A lender sees three things: documented income, assessed payments and the cash you have available. Once you know which of those is pinching, you can work on the right one.
Your first move is simple. Pick one existing balance, usually the line of credit or card with the highest assessed payment. Ask your broker to run the numbers with it kept and with it repaid, before you spend savings or take on extra work just to qualify.
I'm happy to run both scenarios with you, so the decision rests on your real numbers rather than a guess.
Read Next
Standard Charge or Collateral Charge at Renewal? Here is Who Each One Is For
Why Your Pre-Approval Number Is the Wrong Place to Start
Pay Down Total Debt or Lower Your Monthly Payments? Here is Who Each One Is For
Before You Sign an Auto-Renewal: How to Check if Breaking Your Term Pays Off